The 40:1 ratio contains 2.5-fold more d-chiro-inositol than the physiological ovarian requirement (100:1), creating relative DCI excess that impairs oocyte quality, increases FSH requirements, and can block aromatase activity—making it suboptimal for fertility outcomes particularly in assisted reproduction, despite effectiveness for restoring ovulation in insulin-resistant anovulatory patients.

The available evidence suggests the 40:1 myo-inositol to d-chiro-inositol (MI/DCI) ratio demonstrates context-dependent efficacy rather than being universally “wrong” for PCOS and fertility. The ratio appears effective for restoring ovulation in anovulatory, insulin-resistant patients seeking natural conception, but multiple lines of evidence indicate it may be suboptimal for oocyte quality during assisted reproduction. Head-to-head comparisons consistently favor MI over DCI for fertility outcomes in ART contexts, with Isabella et al. demonstrating dose-dependent deterioration in oocyte quality, embryo quality, and FSH requirements as DCI doses increase from 300 to 2400 mg. Mechanistically, the physiological ovarian MI/DCI ratio is 100:1—approximately 2.5-fold higher than the 40:1 ratio used in supplements—suggesting the 40:1 formulation contains excessive DCI relative to ovarian tissue requirements. The “D-chiro-inositol ovarian paradox” explains that increased epimerase activity in PCOS ovaries already creates local MI deficiency, which exogenous DCI at 40:1 may exacerbate rather than correct. Furthermore, high DCI doses can block aromatase expression and paradoxically cause hyperandrogenism, potentially impairing fertility despite systemic metabolic benefits. However, the evidence does not conclusively prove 40:1 is wrong for all PCOS patients: it may represent an acceptable compromise for anovulation when systemic insulin sensitization is needed, but appears excessive for euglycemic patients or those prioritizing oocyte quality in assisted reproduction, where ratios approaching the physiological 100:1 may be preferable.

Read the full report here: Why 40:1 myo-inositol to d-chiro Inositol is wrong for PCOS and Fertility

References